Pug vs French Bulldog comes down to size and lifespan. The Royal Kennel Club gives the Pug, a Toy breed, an ideal weight of 6.3–8.1kg, and the Utility-group French Bulldog 12.5kg for males and 11kg for females. Dogs Trust’s UK data gives the Pug a median lifespan of 11.6 years against 9.8. Both are flat-faced breeds with breathing risks.
We haven’t owned either breed, so this comparison draws on the Royal Kennel Club breed standards, Dogs Trust’s UK longevity study, RVC VetCompass research and PDSA’s breed guides.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Pug vs French Bulldog at a glance
| Pug | French Bulldog | |
|---|---|---|
| Royal Kennel Club group | Toy | Utility |
| RKC size category | Small | Small |
| Height | Not given in the breed standard; PDSA gives an average of 25–33cm | Not given in the breed standard; PDSA gives an average of 30cm |
| Weight | Ideal: 6.3–8.1kg (not split by sex) | Ideal: males 12.5kg, females 11kg |
| Ears | Button or rose | Upright “bat ears” |
| Tail | High set, tightly curled over the hip | Set low, short, preferably straight |
| Coat | Fine, smooth, short and glossy | Fine, smooth, short and close |
| Colours | Silver, apricot, fawn or black | Brindle, fawn or pied |
| Grooming (RKC) | Once a week | Once a week |
| Exercise (RKC) | Up to 1 hour a day | Up to 1 hour a day |
| Breathing test (RKC/Cambridge scheme) | Recommended before breeding | Recommended before breeding |
| Breed Watch | Category 3 | Category 3 |
| UK median lifespan | 11.6 years | 9.8 years |
| UK legal status | Not a banned type | Not a banned type |
Sources: Royal Kennel Club breed standards and breed pages; Dogs Trust’s 2024 UK longevity study; PDSA breed guides (heights only). A breed standard describes the ideal, so individual dogs may be larger or smaller than the sizes given.
A Toy breed and a bull breed: where each comes from
The Pug
The Royal Kennel Club suggests a Chinese liking for small, short-faced dogs may well explain the Pug’s beginnings. Traders from the Dutch East India Company are thought to have brought dogs of this type from China to the Netherlands in the 16th century. When William of Orange took the English throne, his Pugs came with him, and the breed became popular at court.
The RKC calls the Pug the most substantial of its Toy breeds, summed up as “multum in parvo”: a lot of dog in a small frame. It was bred purely as a companion, not for work.
The French Bulldog
Despite the name, the French Bulldog can claim part of its ancestry in Great Britain. The RKC traces it to a dwarf breed known as the Toy Bulldog, popular in parts of the country in the 1850s. Nottingham lace makers facing redundancy during the Industrial Revolution moved to northern France and took their dogs with them.
After some crosses to other short-faced breeds and about three decades, a new breed known as the French Bulldog had evolved. It became fashionable in Paris, appearing in paintings by Degas and Toulouse-Lautrec. The French Bulldog Club of England formed in 1902, and The Kennel Club recognised the breed in 1906.
How to tell a Pug from a French Bulldog
Size and build
The Pug’s standard asks for a dog that is “decidedly square and cobby”, compact and hard-muscled, but never low on the legs or leggy. The French Bulldog’s describes a “sturdy, compact, solid, small dog with good bone”. Both sit in the RKC’s Small size category.
Neither standard gives a height. PDSA puts the Pug’s average at 25–33cm and the French Bulldog’s at 30cm, so the two stand at much the same height. The difference is weight: the Pug’s ideal is 6.3–8.1kg, while the French Bulldog’s is 12.5kg for males and 11kg for females. The Pug’s standard gives one range for males and females alike, and individual dogs vary.
Head, ears and tail
The Pug has a relatively large, round head and a short, blunt, square muzzle that its standard says should not be upfaced, with “well-open nostrils”. Its eyes are dark, relatively large and round, and should never protrude. Its thin, small ears come in two kinds: the button ear, which folds forward, and the rose ear, which folds over and back.
The French Bulldog’s head is square, with a nearly flat skull between the ears and a well-defined muzzle. Its trademark is the “bat ear”: medium-sized, wide at the base, rounded at the top and carried upright. The tails differ too. The Pug’s is set high and tightly curled over the hip, ideally in a double curl; the French Bulldog’s is undocked, set low and preferably straight.
Coat, colours and shedding
Both breeds have a short, smooth coat. The Pug’s standard allows silver, apricot, fawn or black, with a black mask and ears and a black line along the back. The French Bulldog’s correct colours are brindle, fawn and pied, with whites shown as pieds. The Royal Kennel Club will not register merle puppies of either breed, because the merle gene carries a higher risk of hearing and sight problems.
Shedding is where they part company. The RKC notes that Pugs are known to shed considerably despite their short coat, and PDSA says they “can still shed loads”. PDSA says French Bulldogs aren’t known for shedding lots. If you choose a Pug, our guide to deshedding tools covers the options.
Is a French Bulldog a small Bulldog?
No. The Royal Kennel Club lists the Bulldog and the French Bulldog as two separate breeds, both in its Utility group. The link is historical: the RKC traces part of the French Bulldog’s ancestry to the Toy Bulldog of the 1850s. What sets it apart, in the RKC’s words, is that unlike other Bulldog breeds it has large “bat ears”. For the Bulldog itself, including its health and where it stands in UK law, see our Pitbull vs Bulldog guide.
Temperament: what the breed standards and PDSA say
The Pug’s standard describes an “even tempered, happy and lively disposition”, with “great charm, dignity and intelligence”. The French Bulldog’s describes a dog that is “vivacious, deeply affectionate, intelligent”, full of courage yet with clown-like qualities. The RKC calls it “the popular clown of the bull breeds”.
The RKC says Pugs are typically friendly with strangers and good with children when interactions are supervised, but can be strong-willed, which can slow training. Both breeds are people-focused. PDSA says neither should be left alone for more than four hours, and the RKC notes that Pugs can be prone to separation anxiety.
On noise, PDSA says some Pugs “huff” rather than bark, and that French Bulldogs aren’t known for being big barkers unless they are bored or something is wrong. It also says French Bulldogs have a high prey drive and are likely to chase unfamiliar cats and smaller pets.
RVC VetCompass found both breeds were less likely than other dogs to have aggression recorded by their vets. The Pug study’s authors caution against treating this as proof that either breed makes a better family pet. Beyond that, no UK study compares the two breeds on training or barking.
Breathing and BOAS: what UK sources say
The RKC/Cambridge breathing scheme
Brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome (BOAS) happens when the soft tissue in a flat-faced dog’s nose and throat is too much for its airways, making normal breathing hard. The Royal Kennel Club describes it as a progressive disorder that can affect a dog’s ability to exercise, play, eat and sleep.
Both breeds are covered by the Royal Kennel Club and University of Cambridge Respiratory Function Grading Scheme. So is the Shih Tzu, which we compare in our Lhasa Apso vs Shih Tzu comparison. Assessors trained in BOAS can test dogs from 12 months old, and the RKC advises repeating the assessment every two years.
The scheme grades dogs from 0 to 3. Grade 0 dogs are clinically unaffected, and Grade 1 dogs have some breathing noise that doesn’t affect exercise. Grade 2 means moderate signs that should be monitored and may need treatment. Grade 3 means severe signs: the RKC says these dogs should be examined by their own vet and not bred from.
How often UK vets record BOAS
RVC VetCompass studied dogs under UK primary veterinary care in 2016. BOAS was recorded in about 1 in 15 Pugs, compared with about 1 in 1,000 other dogs; even after allowing for age and other factors, Pugs had about 54 times the odds. In French Bulldogs the figure was about 1 in 18, against about 1 in 500 other dogs, with about 31 times the odds.
Narrowed nostrils (stenotic nares), part of the same syndrome, were also strongly linked to both breeds. Both papers say the true figures are probably higher, because owners often treat snoring and noisy breathing as normal for the breed. Each study compared one breed with all other dogs, so the odds shouldn’t be read as a ranking of Pug against French Bulldog.
What judges are asked to watch for
Both breeds are in Category 3 of the Royal Kennel Club’s Breed Watch, which asks show judges to look out for specific points of concern. For the Pug, these include signs of breathing difficulty, pinched nostrils, protruding eyes, excessive skin, skin-fold dermatitis, eye irritation and being too fat. Its standard already calls pinched nostrils and heavy over-nose wrinkle unacceptable.
For the French Bulldog, the list includes signs of breathing difficulty, pinched nostrils, protruding eyes, skin-fold dermatitis, an excessively undershot jaw, a short neck, an exaggerated roach in the topline, and a tail too short to cover the anus or a screw, inverted or tight tail. Its standard says dogs showing respiratory distress or excessive breathing noise are unacceptable.
Treatment for a dog affected by BOAS, including surgery, is a conversation to have with your vet.
Lifespan and health: what UK data shows
Pug vs French Bulldog lifespan in the UK
Dogs Trust’s 2024 study of UK dogs gives the Pug a median lifespan of 11.6 years and the French Bulldog 9.8 years. Both figures come from thousands of dogs, and the gap of almost two years is large enough that it’s unlikely to be chance, so the Pug’s UK median is longer.
Dogs Trust names the French Bulldog among the breeds with the shortest life expectancy in the study. It also found that flat-faced dogs had a 40% higher risk of living shorter lives than dogs with typical-shaped faces. A median describes the breed as a whole, not any one dog.
Pug health
PDSA describes the Pug as a severely flat-faced breed in the RKC’s Category 3, which PDSA calls the highest category of health concerns linked to how a breed looks. The conditions it lists include BOAS; dry eye, corneal ulcers and eye injuries due to shallow eye sockets; eyelid problems; skin-fold infections; luxating patellas; Pug dog encephalitis (PDE); hemivertebrae; elbow and hip dysplasia; Legg-Perthes disease; and hypothyroidism.
In the VetCompass study, corneal ulceration was recorded in about 1 in 15 Pugs, against fewer than 1 in 100 other dogs. Obesity was the most common disorder of all, at about 1 in 6 Pugs compared with about 1 in 14 other dogs. The RKC lists a DNA test for PDE among its recommended tests for breeders.
French Bulldog health
PDSA’s list for the French Bulldog includes BOAS; luxating patellas; dental problems from crowded teeth; eye problems including cataracts; back problems such as intervertebral disc disease (IVDD); skin-fold dermatitis; and hyperuricosuria, which can cause stones or crystals in the urine. The RKC lists a DNA test for one form of hereditary cataract.
In VetCompass, French Bulldogs had about 11 times the odds of skin-fold dermatitis and three times the odds of spinal cord disorders compared with other dogs. Unlike Pugs, they were less likely than other dogs to be recorded as obese.
Before you buy: Ask to see both parents’ results under the Royal Kennel Club and University of Cambridge Respiratory Function Grading Scheme. The RKC also lists eye testing, hip scoring and a PDE DNA test for Pugs, and a cataract DNA test plus elbow, eye and hip screening for French Bulldogs. PDSA advises choosing a puppy with open nostrils from parents whose flat faces and breathing problems are less pronounced. Ask your vet to talk you through the results.
Exercise, heat, home and grooming
The RKC’s breed pages give both breeds the same profile: up to an hour of exercise a day, suited to a flat or apartment with a small or medium garden, and grooming once a week. PDSA suggests splitting that exercise into several shorter walks, with play and brain games in between.
Heat is the bigger concern. PDSA warns that French Bulldogs can overheat quickly and that Pugs are at higher risk of heatstroke, so in warm weather walk them early in the morning or later in the evening and watch closely for signs of struggling. For lead and harness choices, see our dog harness vs collar guide.
Both breeds have facial skin folds that PDSA says should be kept clean and dry. The RKC notes dental crowding in Pugs, and PDSA says flat-faced breeds like the French Bulldog often have crowded teeth, so tooth care matters. Our guide to cleaning dog teeth without brushing covers the alternatives.
When to see your vet: PDSA advises speaking to a vet if your Pug snorts, snores or breathes loudly, because these can be signs of BOAS rather than normal breed noises. Both breeds are vulnerable in the heat, so walk them early or late in warm weather and stop if they start to struggle for breath.
Which breed suits which owner
Neither breed suits a home where it would be left alone for long. Both need someone around most of the day, gentle exercise and care in warm weather. A Pug brings heavier shedding and fold care, and its weight needs watching; a French Bulldog sheds less but may chase cats it doesn’t know.
PDSA is unusually direct about both. Its vets strongly recommend considering a breed with a normal snout rather than a Pug, and it suggests considering a different breed to avoid some of the French Bulldog’s problems. If you go ahead with either, choose a breeder whose dogs have been through the breathing scheme. For other pairings, browse our breed guides.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which lives longer, a Pug or a French Bulldog?
The Pug, by almost two years on UK data. Dogs Trust’s 2024 UK study gives the Pug a median lifespan of 11.6 years and the French Bulldog 9.8 years, and the gap is unlikely to be chance. Dogs Trust lists the French Bulldog among the breeds with the shortest life expectancy.
Do Pugs and French Bulldogs both have breathing problems?
Yes, both are at risk of BOAS, a breathing disorder linked to flat faces. RVC VetCompass found it recorded in about 1 in 15 Pugs and 1 in 18 French Bulldogs under UK vet care in 2016, against about 1 in 500 or fewer other dogs. Both breeds are covered by the RKC/Cambridge breathing grading scheme.
Which is bigger, a Pug or a French Bulldog?
The French Bulldog is heavier. The Royal Kennel Club gives it an ideal weight of 12.5kg for males and 11kg for females, against 6.3–8.1kg for the Pug. Neither standard gives a height, but PDSA’s averages of 25–33cm and 30cm put the two at much the same height.
Do Pugs shed more than French Bulldogs?
Yes. The Royal Kennel Club notes that Pugs are known to shed considerably despite their short coats, and PDSA says they can still shed loads. PDSA says French Bulldogs aren’t known for shedding lots. The RKC recommends grooming both breeds once a week.
Is a French Bulldog the same as a Bulldog?
No. The Royal Kennel Club lists them as separate breeds, both in its Utility group. It traces part of the French Bulldog’s ancestry to the Toy Bulldog, popular in Britain in the 1850s, and notes that unlike other Bulldog breeds the French Bulldog has large, upright “bat ears”.
How much exercise do Pugs and French Bulldogs need?
Up to an hour a day for both, according to the Royal Kennel Club. PDSA suggests splitting it into shorter walks. Both breeds are vulnerable in the heat, so in warm weather walk them early in the morning or later in the evening, and stop if they struggle to breathe.
